We may receive compensation through links to providers. Read our editorial approach and disclosure.
By Aurum Meridian · Sources checked 22 October 2026. Editorial approach.
You can sell silver to a bullion dealer, a local coin shop, a jewelry or scrap buyer, or a specialist auction business. The useful comparison is which buyer accepts your exact items and offers the highest net payment after shipping, insurance, testing and other deductions. An advertised price alone cannot answer that question.
This guide separates ordinary bullion from jewelry and collectibles, then gives you a quote worksheet. Buyer policies cited below are examples of terms to check, not a ranking or a promise that a company will buy your items.
Match the buyer to the silver you have
| Your items | Possible route | Question before committing |
|---|---|---|
| Recognizable bullion coins, rounds or bars | Bullion dealer or coin shop | What is the bid for this product, quantity and condition? |
| Sterling jewelry or flatware | Buyer that explicitly accepts sterling or scrap | How are non-silver parts, testing and refining deducted? |
| Rare coins, antique silver or signed pieces | Relevant specialist dealer or auction business | Is the offer for metal alone or for the collectible item? |
| Silver-plated or unidentified objects | Buyer willing to identify that material | Is this accepted, and will identification or return shipping cost anything? |
The FTC’s silver-marking guide explains that sterling is 92.5% silver, while silver plate is a layer applied over another metal. A stamp is useful information to photograph, but an offer may still depend on inspection. Avoid treating the entire weight of a plated object as silver.
Also separate weighted objects from solid pieces. APMEX’s sterling guide describes filled handles and other non-silver components that can make an object’s total weight misleading. Tell each buyer what you know and what remains unidentified; do not turn a kitchen-scale reading into a claimed fine-silver weight.
Compare the payment you would actually receive
Estimated net payment = gross offer − shipping and insurance − assay or refining charges − other sale fees. “Assay” means testing the metal’s composition. Ask whether that test is required and whether its charge is already included in the bid.
| Quote | Gross offer | Shipping / insurance | Assay / other fees | Estimated net |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | $620 | $24 | $12 | $584 |
| B | $600 | $0 | $0 | $600 |
Quote B leaves $16 more in this example despite its lower headline offer. These figures exclude tax and assume the buyer accepts the described items. Mark unknown costs as “unconfirmed,” rather than entering zero. If testing can change the amount, record the net figure as provisional.
Request quotes close together using the same inventory. Record the time, currency and expiry of each quote so a market movement or different item description does not masquerade as a better deal.
Online policies show why the small print matters
APMEX’s selling FAQ currently states a $1,000 minimum transaction and offers shipping and insurance at discounted rates through its logistics service. That is not a blanket promise of free shipping. Its FAQ also limits purchases from international customers to items held at a Citadel Depository.
JM Bullion’s selling terms, section 7, say sellers bear shipping costs, including costs deducted when using certain prepaid labels. It may revise an offer after inspection if the items differ from their description, and return shipping can fall to the seller. A prepaid label therefore does not necessarily mean the postage is free.
Check the policy for the particular program you intend to use. Bullion, jewelry and scrap programs can have different minimums, accepted items and payment arrangements, even within one company.
If you are uncertain about a coin, use our silver-coin authenticity checklist before arranging a sale. Match the exact issue and understand the limits of home observations.
Get these answers before handing over or shipping silver
- Acceptance: Send an inventory with quantities, markings, condition and photographs. Confirm the buyer accepts that category and lot size.
- Price commitment: Ask when the bid becomes binding, what remains subject to inspection, and which shipping deadline applies. Understand cancellation or market-loss charges before accepting.
- Testing: Ask whether testing is destructive, whether permission is required, and how disputed purity or weight is handled.
- Delivery: Get packing instructions, approved carrier details, insurance limits and responsibility for loss in writing.
- Payment: Record the payment method, fees and expected processing period after acceptance.
- Rejected items: Confirm who pays for their return and whether you can decline a revised offer.
Which route pays the most?
There is no universally highest-paying route established by these policies. For a small lot, shipping can outweigh a stronger online bid. For a collectible, request an explanation of any value beyond its metal content before comparing it with a scrap quote. Compare the final terms for your items, including the time and costs involved.
If you are also comparing companies for a future purchase, our precious-metals company directory covers that separate decision. Company placement there does not establish who will pay most for your silver. Aurum Meridian may receive compensation from featured partners; the policy links in this guide are research sources.
